Skip to main content

Texas State Library and Archives Commission Meeting
Libraries and Talking Book Committee
March 10, 2023
Minutes

The Libraries and Talking Book Committee of the Texas State Library and Archives Commission met on March 10, 2023, via videoconference.

Committee Members Present:

Darryl Tocker, Committee Chairman
Arthur Mann (videoconference)
Bradley Tegeler (videoconference)
 

 

Commissioners Present via Video:

Chair Martha Wong

 

Staff Present:

Gloria Meraz, Director and Librarian
Tim Gleisner, Assistant State Librarian
Sarah Swanson, General Counsel
Sarah Karnes, Director, Library Development and Networking
Ann Minner, Director, Talking Books Program
 

 

Guests via video:

None

 

Guests present:

None

 

Guests present via video:

None

1.    Welcome and Introductions

Chairman Darryl Tocker called the meeting to order on March 10, 2023, at 10:00 a.m. and stated that notice of this meeting was filed with the Secretary of State on March 1, 2023. He welcomed everyone to the meeting.

2.    Roll Call for Members and Establishment of a Quorum

Chairman Tocker took a roll call of committee members and established a quorum was present. Chairman Tocker and Committee members Arthur Mann and Bradley Tegeler were in attendance. He noted that Commission Chair Martha Wong was also present via video, though she, and any other commissioners not on the committee who joined the meeting, would attend only for information-gathering purposes and would not be voting on any action item of the committee, nor would any action of the full commission be taken.

3.    Public Comment

No public comments were received.

4.    Approval of Minutes of the Libraries and Talking Book Committee Meeting, October 18, 2022

Commissioner Arthur Mann moved to approve the minutes of the October 18, 2022, committee meeting. Commissioner Bradley Tegeler seconded the motion.

Chairman Tocker conducted a roll call vote. All committee members voted in favor and the motion passed unanimously.

5.    Update on Initiatives from the Library Development and Networking Division

a.    Targeted Review of School Library Programs: Standards and Guidelines for Texas. Sarah Karnes reported that the agency’s school library standards workgroup has made significant progress on the development of new guidance on collection management since its first meeting late last summer.  She noted the group created a list of topic areas and is working to complete best practices in these categories. The new guidance will be presented as a defined set of practices for implementation of a strong collection development.  The group’s research included a public survey last fall to gather feedback from parents and community members as to how they want to communicate and work with school library programs.

Ms. Karnes also welcomed Vanessa Ashcraft, who joined TSLAC in February as the new School Program Coordinator, and who will lead the workgroup going forward.  The draft guidelines are planned to be ready for review by the State Board of Education (SBOE) and then by the commissioners in summer 2023, with the goal of providing the guidelines to school districts for the 2023-2024 academic year.

This led to a discussion on the process and timeline of adopting the guidelines.

b.    Process to Review Public Library Accreditation Standards. Ms. Karnes reported that the Library Systems Act (Government Code, Chapter 441, Subsection I) requires the agency to establish and develop 13 TAC Chapter 1, Subchapter C, Minimum Standards for Accreditation of Libraries in the State Library System.  The standards were last updated in November of 2014.  The agency has historically developed accreditation standards in consultation with the library community, and so the agency intends to follow a similar process now.

Ms. Karnes then gave an overview of the anticipated timeline of reviewing the current standards, creating the draft revisions, reaching out to stakeholders and engaging the library community for feedback and comments, and the process of presenting to the commissioners the proposed amendments for publication in the Texas Register for public comments and, later, the proposed amendments for adoption. She briefly commented on some focus areas of interest for possible revision.

Ms. Karnes also clarified that review of the rules for accreditation standards takes place every 10 years.  Reaccreditation of libraries takes place every year.  A list of accredited libraries is posted on the TSLAC website.

c.    Programs and Services. Ms. Karnes highlighted current activities of the Library Development and Networking (LDN) division of TSLAC.  LDN completed a Texas public library internet speed test in February to collect data about internet speeds for Texas libraries, including 347 main libraries and 176 branch libraries representing 361 systems. This data allows LDN to better determine statewide needs for broadband and secure funding for broadband development where it’s needed.  LDN is also working to put together a report on the results of the speed test as well as data mapping.

TSLAC’s E-Read services is currently assisting libraries to help them meet the March deadline to secure funding for E-Read.  

Ms. Karnes reported that LDN continues to provide director training for a program that was first launched in the fall.  The training, which has served 64 new directors statewide, included focus areas in the spring that will continue through the summer.  LDN has also provided collection development workshops in nine locations in the state, which focuses on the collection development policies of the participants and where they may be improved upon.

Ms. Karnes then reported that the data collection portal for collecting annual public library reports for FY2022 for accreditation will soon be open. The agency receives reports from 525 Texas public libraries.  In general, over 90% of the libraries meet the standard minimum requirements of accreditation annually.

Gloria Meraz also noted that LDN will be participating in a resource sharing summit with stakeholders to rethink and revisit E-Read resources statewide, including available content, how funding is spent, and the needs of the libraries.

This was a discussion item only. No action was taken.

6.    Update on the Talking Book Program

a.    Discussion of Proposed Amendments to 13 TAC Chapter 9, Talking Book Program. Sarah Swanson reported that the agency will be reviewing 13 TAC Chapter 9 and proposing amendments.  She noted that state agencies are required to conduct reviews of all their adopted rules every four years. The commissioners approved the review of Chapter 9 during the November 11, 2022, meeting, and the notice of intent to review the rules was  on December 9, 2022.

Ms. Swanson gave an overview of the proposed changes and noted that much of the changes are meant to improve the rules overall as well as update and/or clarify terminology used.  The proposed amendments will be shared with the commissioners during the April 2023 Commission meeting.

b.    iPad Deployment. Ann Minner reported that the commissioners approved the use of the American Rescue Plan for the purchase of iPads to support access to the National Library Services’ Braille and Audio Reading Download program and to foster digital literacy skills, and opportunities for patrons of the Talking Book Program.  The commissioners additionally approved the procurement of a mobile device manager, a software tool to facilitate maintenance and management of the devices.  That procurement is currently underway.  TBP created and recently posted for a digital literacy trainer position to focus, for the first few years, on the iPad Project.

c.    Programs and Services. Ms. Minner highlighted current activities of the Talking Book Program (TBP) division of TSLAC.  In addition to having an open position for the digital literacy trainer, TBP also has vacancies for the bibliographic control and interlibrary loan librarian as well as a manager of reader services.  TBP also recently hired a new reader services consultant and an audio technician.

Ms. Minner then reported on advertising initiatives through social media platforms to campaign TBP’s free services to eligible Texans. TBP also has digital content in the Texas Highways Magazine for this month.  Additionally, TBP is working with the agency’s communications team as well as the Communications Office to create an animated, informational video to send to parents of children signed up with TBP because of reading disabilities.

Ms. Minner then noted that TBP holds a phone-in book club every month.  TBP is also working with Austin Public Library to build a StoryWalk at Windsor Branch that will include braille overlays.  Plans for the National Library Service (NLS) Summer Reading Program are underway. Presentations for the Texas Library Association Conference in April are also being prepared by TBP staff.

NLS has several projects that TBP is involved with.  The recording studio has about 70 active volunteers, and its audio technicians have uploaded nearly 1,900 Texas books into BARD.  TBP has also received 300 ZoomaX Braille E-Readers that staff are being trained on, to be sent out to patrons.  TBP will also be a pilot location for the updated digital Talking Book Machine, which connects to BARD and accepts cartridges.

This led to a conversation about tracking what platforms best advertise TBP’s services as well as compatibility of the equipment TBP sends out to patrons with other devices.

This was an information item only. No action was taken.

7.    Adjournment

Commissioner Mann moved to adjourn the meeting and Commissioner Tegeler seconded. The motion carried unanimously.

Chairman Tocker adjourned the meeting at 10:49 a.m.
 



Page last modified: May 7, 2025