Skip to main content

Texas State Library and Archives Commission Meeting
Audit Committee
Minutes

October 25, 2024

The Texas State Library and Archives Commission Audit Committee met in person on Friday, October 25, 2024, 10:00 a.m. at the Lorenzo de Zavala State Archives and Library Building, 1201 Brazos Street, Austin, Texas.

Committee Members Present:

Bradley S. Tegeler, Chair
Darryl Tocker
David Garza (videoconference)
 

 

Other Commissioner Present:

Martha Wong (videoconference)
 

 

Staff Present:

Gloria Meraz, Director and Librarian
Tim Gleisner, Assistant State Librarian
Sarah Swanson, General Counsel
Robert Pierce, Facility and Security Manager
Sarah Karnes, Division Director, Library Development and Networking
Cyan Green, Executive Assistant
Mike Ford, ITS Director, Information Technology Services
David Powers, Desktop Support Specialist, Information Technology Services
Geegana Wickremasiri, Desktop Support Specialist, Information Technology Services
 

 

Staff Via Video:

Donna Osborne, Chief Operations and Fiscal Officer
Jelain Chubb, Division Director, Archives and Information Services
 

 

Guests Present Via Video:

Daniel Graves, Weaver
Michael Karnes, Weaver
Charles Smith, Legislative Budget Board
 

 

1. Welcome and Introductions

Committee Chair Bradley Tegeler welcomed everyone and called the meeting to order at 10:02 a.m. He stated that notice of this meeting was posted with the Secretary of State on October 15, 2024, and that the notice indicated the meeting would be conducted via videoconference and provided a phone number and web link for the public to use to access the meeting.

2. Roll Call for Members

Committee Chair Tegeler took a roll call of committee members and established a quorum. In addition to Committee Chair Tegeler, Commissioners Darryl Tocker and David Garza were present. Chair Tegeler reported that Commission Chair Martha Wong was also present, and he noted that any commissioners not on the Committee were attending only for information-gathering purposes and would not vote on any action item of the Committee, nor would any action of the Commission be taken.

3. Approval of Minutes of Audit Committee Meeting of August 2, 2024

Committee Chair Tocker moved to approve the minutes of the August 2, 2024, Audit Committee meeting. Commissioner Garza seconded the motion. The minutes were approved unanimously.

4. Public Comment

No public comment was received.

5. Internal Audit Status Follow-up Report on Information Technology General Controls

Donna Osborne introduced Daniel Graves and Michael Karnes—both representing Weaver, the agency’s outsourced internal audit vendor—who would provide updates on TSLAC’s internal audit reports.

Commissioner Tegeler asked that this item be deferred for discussion for executive session due to the sensitivity of the audit report on information technology services.

6. Audit Report on Risk Management

Mr. Karnes gave an overview of the completed FY 2024 Internal Audit Report on Risk Management. He noted that this audit reviewed the agency’s in-place processes for insurance, volunteers, and State Office of Risk Management (SORM) reviews. The audit focused on two objectives in these areas: A) internal control, design, and objective, and B) internal control test of effectiveness.

Under objective A, Mr. Karnes reported that there was one low-risk finding in the volunteer process area. Weaver recommended that the agency update their procedures and then review them regularly to ensure they stay current, which the agency has started.

The overall risk management process received a strong rating.

Under objective B, there were no additional findings identified under insurance, volunteers, or SORM reviews for effectiveness of the controls.

7. Audit Report on Payroll

Mr. Karnes gave an overview of the scope of FY 2024 Internal Audit Report on Payroll, including timekeeping and approval, payroll processing, payroll taxes, voluntary deductions, garnishments, and accrued leave. The audit focused on two objectives in these areas: A) internal control, design, and objective, and B) internal control test of effectiveness.

Mr. Graves then reported that the overall report has a strong rating with no findings.

Responding to a question presented by Commissioner Tocker, Ms. Osborne confirmed that the agency’s payroll is centrally processed.

8. Audit Advisory Report on Facilities and Maintenance

Ms. Osborne reported that the Texas Facilities Commission (TFC) is responsible for facilities and maintenance duties of TSLAC-operated facilities at the Lorenzo de Zavala building and State Records Center / Talking Book Circulation in Austin, Texas. The Sam Houston Regional Library and Research Center (SHC) in Liberty, Texas is more directly under the control of TSLAC, and so the agency consulted with the auditors to determine the best means to evaluate various processes at the existing facilities and maintenance projects at SHC.

Mr. Graves explained that Weaver follows internal audit standards under the Texas Internal Audit Act, and The Institute of Internal Auditors allows two standards: audit and consulting. Weaver approached this report under standards for consulting, which allowed Weaver to approach the issue in a more advisory role.

Mr. Graves then noted that Weaver defined several areas of focus—including job costing, project management and execution, and project timeliness and closures—from which Weaver identified four issues to be addressed by the agency.

A low-risk concern came from identifying a contract that had not been closed out after completion of the project.

A moderate-risk concern came from the agency’s communication of project needs. Currently, TSLAC has a list of projects at SHC relating to maintenance needs. Historically, the agency has shared these maintenance issues with TFC and contracted with TFC for repairs. However, Weaver advised the agency to communicate the entirety of the list with TFC to better indicate the magnitude of maintenance and repair work still needed. Mr. Graves noted that the hope in sharing the scope of what is needed in its entirety will help TFC build a project timeline and dedicate resources to resolving issues or allow TSLAC to find third-party project managers to ensure that the projects are completed in a timely manner and with a lower long-term cost.

Weaver also looked at the return of investment concept as well as the number of overall and per person onsite visits, number of contacts, and who used the facilities. Between 2013 – 2024, Mr. Graves noted an overall decline in visitor attendance, which matches a larger national trend with similar facilities.

A high-risk concern came from outdated estimates of facilities maintenance. Mr. Graves noted that there is an estimated 24% gap between initial and current estimate costs.

A high-risk concern came from anticipating an increase in the cost of deferred maintenance and market conditions. Mr. Graves noted that Weaver anticipates a 5% compounded increase based on the length of time a project is deferred year-to-year.

Commission Tocker asked whether the increased cost of estimated maintenance reflected costs by contracting with TFC. Mr. Graves explained that the estimated cost is based on the public market, reasoning that TFC would subcontract for repair and maintenance of this scale.

Ms. Meraz explained that the agency is working to create a comprehensive view of maintenance and repair projects currently in process as well as which projects the agency wants prioritized. By sharing the full breadth of issues, the agency hopes to find a path that most efficiently addresses the needs of the facilities. Additionally, the historic buildings have been left in a state in which deterioration is inevitable without attention.

Committee Chair Tegeler noted that paying the full cost earlier to have the upkeep of the SHC facilities is likely to save costs overall versus working on repairs over an extended period.

Jelain Chubb noted that the audit helped clarify issues, and she agreed with the recommendation of sharing information with TFC with a current, comprehensive list of needed projects and priorities.

Commissioner Wong asked if Weaver could send a brief letter to the Commission presenting their recommendation, which would in turn help the agency present their request to the Legislative Budget Board for funding.

9. FY 2024 Annual Internal Audit Report

Ms. Osborne noted that the agency is required every year to provide an internal audit report and submit it to the State Auditor’s Office, oversight entities, and the outsource internal auditor for the agency.

Mr. Graves gave an overview of the FY 2024 Annual Internal Audit Report and update of reports from FY 2024. He noted that there are a total of three open outstanding findings—excluding anything related to ITS, which is hidden for security reasons—which include two findings under record center services and one under risk management.

Mr. Graves then gave an overview of the FY 2025 Audit Plan, in which it was proposed that audits were performed on information security, resource sharing, and broadband grants; as well as follow-up on the three open findings noted earlier for record center services and risk management. The FY 2025 Audit Plan was approved by the Commission at the August 2024 meeting.

Responding to a question presented by Commissioner Tocker, Gloria Meraz noted that the application process for broadband grants begins in spring of 2025. Mr. Graves stated that the evaluation for broadband grants would be subject to a review of the agency’s process to administer the grants and can be reviewed before and after the implementation of the program.

Commissioner Tocker motioned to accept the FY 2024 Annual Internal Audit Report to present it to full commission. Commissioner Garza seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously.

10. Audit Report on the Library and Archives Commission’s Compliance with HUB and State Use Program Requirements

Ms. Osborne reported that the State Auditor’s Office (SAO) conducted an audit of the agency’s compliance with requirements of the State’s Historically Underutilized Business (HUB) and State Use Programs during the audit term of September 2022 through February 2024. She noted that a copy of this report—which contains the objective and scope of the audit, the methodology used to for findings, SAO’s recommendations, and TSLAC’s response—has already been submitted to the State Audit Legislative Audit Committee and the Office of the Governor. The report is posted on the SAO’s website.

Of note, TSLAC complied with HUB planning and contracting requirements and most HUB outreach and contracting requirements. SAO reported that there was a low-risk finding in the agency’s HUB program compliance and medium-risk findings in the agency’s HUB reporting and State Use Program.

For HUB program compliance, the agency is required to provide all procurement opportunities to all the agency’s current vendors. Ms. Osborne explained that the agency had earlier interpreted that it was sufficient that the Comptroller provide the notice through the Electronic State Business Daily but has been since notified that this does not cover the agency’s responsibilities to submit procurement opportunities separately and independently. TSLAC will make those corrections going forward.

Additionally, it was recommended that the agency participate in more HUB events, in which state agencies invite HUB vendors to an event to present procurement opportunities that could potentially be awarded.

Ms. Osborne then gave an overview of the finding for HUB reporting, noting that SAO recommended that the agency strengthen the HUB reporting process for expenditures, contracts awarded, and bids received. She noted that the agency is looking into its internal records to ensure accurate records for reporting and is making changes to its regular process for reviewing and approving data.

Ms. Osborne then gave an overview of the finding for State Use Program, noting that SAO recommended that the agency strengthen its reporting process of program exceptions or expenditures. The agency is looking into its internal records to ensure accurate records for reporting and making changes to its regular process for reviewing and approving data.

11. Executive Session

The Committee went into executive session under the exceptions related to consultation with attorney at 10:55 a.m., and Chair Tegeler called the open meeting back to order at 11:08 a.m.

12. Action Items from Executive Session

Chair Tegeler reported that there were no action item resulting from the executive session.

13. Adjournment

Commissioner Garza made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Commissioner Tocker seconded the motion. The motion carried, and the meeting adjourned at 11:09 a.m.
 



Page last modified: August 12, 2025