Z TEXAS MEETING
Friday, November 10 2000
9:00 - 4:00
TLA Board Room
3355 Bee Cave Road, Suite 401
Austin, TX 78746-6763
Home | Implementation Resources
(Bold purple text indicates work we said we would do)
Virginia Allen, Lamar University, firstname.lastname@example.org
Teresa Ashley, Austin Community College, email@example.com
Sharon Castleberry, Coppell Public Library, firstname.lastname@example.org
Esther Crawford, Rice University, email@example.com
Jack Drost, Rice University, firstname.lastname@example.org
Bob Gaines, Central Texas Library System, email@example.com
Holly Gordon, Texas State Library and Archives Commission, firstname.lastname@example.org
Cathy Hartman, University of North Texas, email@example.com
Rebecca Linton, Texas State Library and Archives Commission, firstname.lastname@example.org
Slavko, Manojlovich, University of Newfoundland/SIRSI, email@example.com
Connie Moss, Coppell Public Library, firstname.lastname@example.org
Bill Mott, Epixtech, email@example.com
Allen Mullen, Texas State Library and Archives Commission, firstname.lastname@example.org
Christine Peterson, Amigos Library Services, email@example.com
Beverley Shirley, Texas State Library and Archives Commission, firstname.lastname@example.org
Gail Wanner, Epixtech, email@example.com
Sheila Williams, Euless Public Library, firstname.lastname@example.org
- Welcome to Austin and thanks to the Texas Library Association for hosting this meeting!
- Christine Peterson served as interim chair for this meeting as Bill Moen was not able to attend and Bob Gaines had to leave early for another meeting
From Last Meeting:
NISO American National Profile
- A committee was created Bill Moen is chairing it; Christine Peterson is on it.
- Timetable states that this standard should be available by the end of summer 2001.
- Next NISO meeting before ALA Midwinter -- January 10-11/Washington, DC; next (and final) meeting in Dallas area March 15-April 15
- To keep up: www.unt.edu/zprofile/
- Bill Moen received grant from IMLS for looking at standards/levels of interoperability for Bath and Z Texas Profiles
- Two-year grant
Free Z Client
- Bob Gaines is working with Rob Bull; client is close to completion
- Looking for Z servers to include as targets within the client; North Richland Hills Public Library is only target at this time
- Analogous to a "Z-Toaster;" should be so simple to use (to search and retrieve MARC records) that most librarians can figure it out
- Please contact Bob with Z server information to include in client
Outstanding issues on Z Texas from last meeting:
- ZIG will give us a use attribute for Sears subject headings; number has not been given yet
Date of Acquisition for Level 3
- Checked with TSLAC Archives; not important at this time, so TZIG will not pursue
- Discussion concerning the importance of date of acquisition for archives and special collections; this is included in the CIMI Profile, so it is possible that they can use CIMI instead of or in addition to Z Texas.
- Form/Genre and Function for Level 3 -- already searchable via subject field search, so will not pursue
- TIF is open to including money for Z39.50 re-mapping and indexing in their future RFPs; we will look at draft language for future RFPs later in meeting
Indexing guidelines -- Bill Moen created a discussion list for this:
- email@example.com | subscribe libcatindexing yourname
- There is a lot of interest in this at the national level; it would be best if Texas becomes part of that discussion by subscribing to this discussion list. At this point, we will let others handle it.
- It is very important to get Texas catalogers and reference librarians on this list. Bill will start the discussion soon.
Chris contact Margery Tibbetts re: full-text indexing
- No answer from Margery, however other inquiries seem to indicate that most everyone uses MARC-based data; we have some leads on other places using GRS
- Do we want to deal with MARC only databases? Will discuss later in the agenda
Discussion of Chair/Co-Chairs -- Bob Gaines
Two new co-chairs to replace Bill Moen and Bob Gaines:
- Cathy Hartman, University of North Texas
- Christine Peterson, Amigos Library Services
Maintenance of TZIG Web Site -- Beverley Shirley
- TSLAC will continue to house the TZIG documents -- www.tsl.texas.gov/ld/projects/z3950/index.html. However, with the increased load on TSLAC staff, additional help in updating TZIG web pages will be needed.
Beverley Shirley is the TSLAC contact. Thanks to these volunteers:
- Esther Crawford, Rice University
- Virginia Allen, Lamar University (in a couple of months)
- Sheila Williams, Euless Public Library
Maintenance of Z Texas Profile
- TSLAC will continue to house the Z Texas Profile. However, we need someone to help maintain it, e.g., make it come into compliance with the Bath and NISO American National Profiles. Thanks to Teresa Ashley of Austin Community College, for your help!
Release 2.0 of Z Texas Profile
Release 2.0 supercedes earlier releases. It is available in two locations at present:
Possible changes to Bath -- Comment Period Ends 11/23/00
- Bath Profile Maintenance Agency -- www.collectionscanada.ca/bath/ap-bath-e.htm
- Bath Profile -- www.ukoln.ac.uk/interop-focus/bath/
- Bath discussion list: firstname.lastname@example.org | subscribe bath-profile-l your name
- Amendments to Bath Profile:
- Incorporates some of our Category 2 searches
Changes of concern:
- Bath is adding numerous serial title searches
Record syntax: XML gone in level 0 in both Functional Area A (Bibliographic Search and Retrieval) and C (Cross-Domain Search and Retrieval); current proposal:
- client: (unimarc or MARC21) and SUTRS
- server: (unimarc or MARC21) and SUTRS
- If no changes are made, to this proposal, TZIG decided we will require Level 1 for both Functional Areas A and C for clients
- Cathy Hartman and Christine Peterson will send our concern to Bath list on behalf of TZIG.
- Individual comments are welcome -- please send them either to the Bath discussion list or Carrol Lunau (see above)
- Teresa Ashley will include language in Z Texas introductory section that states that TZIG can recommend additions to the National Profile
State document number search
- Would searching of all states' document numbers be helpful? Because of inconsistency in classification systems used for state-level document numbers, TZIG would prefer to have a search just for the Texas State Document Number (086, first indicator blank, subfield 2 "txdoc")
- Others states at NISO meeting would like to search their own state's document numbers
- Christine Peterson will ask for another new use attribute from Ray Denenberg (Library of Congress) for Texas State Document Number; Cathy Hartman will write justification for state-level searches
- TZIG created a single subject search that included both LC and LC Children's Headings; NISO Profile will probably create two separate searches; we will incorporate.
- Amendment 2 deals with retrieval of holdings; at this point, it is minimal, but a step in the right direction; leave this section for national/international groups
TSLAC/TRAIL Bath Implementation Status Report
TSLAC's online catalog (SIRSI) and TRAIL (searches Texas state agency web sites) have implemented both the Z Texas and Bath Profiles. As far as we know, this is the first implementation of either Profile.
Allen Mullen (TSLAC) demonstrated TRAIL
- Can search both TRAIL and TSLAC library catalog
- TRAIL is set up to deal with any Z client; however, some of the functions Z Texas allows you to do cannot be done by a server; for example, your system may not be able to use all attributes; inconsistency in indexing is also a problem
Slavko Manojlovich (University of Newfoundland, SIRSI) worked with both TSLAC and Blue Angel to make this work
- Both clients are searching two different databases -- MARC 21 and DC; had to map between two databases
- On SIRSI Unicorn, used indexing guidelines -- Bath level 0 and 1; had firewall problems; tried making interface look similar -- same labels; mapped very closely;
- At first, TRAIL had two different indexes -- one for TRAIL and one for Bath; wouldn't do it again as it caused problems for entry; definitely doable; we need more implementations; guidance documents on how to do it
Slavko is working on creating an Austin area virtual union catalog; using it as a test for a possible state-wide version
- Problems: no response from some library Z servers so he has had to contact vendors to see why they aren't working; second problem is firewall problem; in order to make this work, libraries need buy-in: why would they want to have a geographic area VUC?
Allen Mullen -- need to start working on implementation; re-visit why Z39.50 is good? for librarians? for users?
- Libraries believe they have a Z client and server, but don't
- UNT -- they get students from the North Texas area who want to use the resources from their local libraries
- Create a tool-kit section of web site? resources that will help when you are ready to implement on a local level? Allen would help; Virginia to help in three months
Holly -- demo SIRSI Z39.50 Profile searches of:
- Other Libraries
- Z3950 Sites
- Now have to search library catalog and TRAIL separately; soon will search both at same time under Z39.50 Sites
Possible Wording Change for Grants from Telecommunications Infrastructure Fund
Current wording in TIF grants is very generic -- usually only using phrases such as library having to support "an http or Z39.50 connection to the Internet" by the end of the grant period or purchasing a "Z39.50 server module." In order to tighten up this language and include funding for possible re-indexing and/or re-mapping of databases to conform to the Z Texas Profile, Christine Peterson will bring this language will before the TIF Library Working Group for their possible adoption in the Glossary of future RFPs:
- Z39.50 Functionality -- includes client and/or server Z39.50 costs; software, mapping, and re-indexing must conform to the current release of the Z Texas Profile (see www.tsl.texas.gov/ld/projects/z3950/index.html for profile as well as guidance documents)
Possible language for Appendix B: TIF Minimum Specifications
Z39.50 functionality for both clients and servers must conform, as a minimum, to the Z Texas Profile. Libraries may purchase the client and/or the server portion.
Acceptable costs for Z39.50 clients include:
- Z39.50 client software or upgrade
Acceptable costs for Z39.50 servers include:
- Z39.50 server software or upgrade
- Z39.50 server (includes hardware and operating system) or upgrade
- Indexing or re-indexing of library database to conform to Z Texas Profile standard
- Mapping or re-mapping of library database to conform to Z Texas Profile standard.
- Acceptable costs for Z39.50 clients include:
- Z39.50 functionality for both clients and servers must conform, as a minimum, to the Z Texas Profile. Libraries may purchase the client and/or the server portion.
Guidance Documents for Z Texas ProfileUsing a list of guidance documents from prior meetings, the group discussed what documents were necessary and who could work on them.
Include on web site a general section on Z39.50:
- Most of this has been done and can be linked
- Virginia Allen will find IMSLIC information
- Teresa Ashley will do basic search to find documents for this section
- Cathy Hartman wrote an article for Mississippi Libraries -- will check to see if we can link to it
- Christine Peterson will write an article for North Texas Regional Library System -- will ask to link to it
- The Bath Profile and Why Should I Care? www.ukoln.ac.uk/interop-focus/activities/z3950/int_profile/bath/draft/prof.doc
- Z39.50 For All: www.ariadne.ac.uk/issue21/z3950/
- Z39.50: The User's Perspective: www.dlib.org/dlib/april97/cornell/04payette.html
- The Z Texas Project: Implementing Z39.50 to Improve Statewide Access to Catalogs and Other Online Resources -- www.txla.org/pubs/tlj74_4/moen.html
- Powerpoint presentation from Virginia Allen
Include on web Texas web site a tool kit section, providing practical advice on implementation:
Allen Mullen (TSLAC) and Virginia Allen (Lamar) will work on this
How to Talk to Your Vendor -- we think it was done, but don't know where it is -- Christine Peterson will check with Saralyn Shone
Z Texas Profile as a checklist -- originally from Bill Moen, but will not do
List of Z servers in Texas -- will check with Bob Gaines
Guidance on using Z39.50 with a firewall -- the National Library of Canada is working on this; we can link to them
Comparison of 10-12 vendors and their Bath Level 0 conformance -- Slavko Manojlovich will be presenting; can link to it when finished
Allen and Virginia will head these up:
Anecdotal information about implementations
Bath compliant libraries
Z Texas compliant libraries
List of strong subject areas in Texas libraries? Govt docs has done it; IPEG (ILL Implementers Group) is looking at it
Library of Texas (LOT)
- One piece of the Library of Texas is the virtual union catalog. Z39.50 will most likely be the backbone of this project. After listening to an overview of this project, we will discuss with TSLAC possible ways the TZIG can aid in this implementation.
- TSLAC Library Resource Sharing Division (LRSD) will set up a committee for each part of LOT; Deborah was originally to head the virtual catalog committee, but she is leaving for LDD position; another person will be selected. Rebecca Linton, Allen Mullen, and Beverley Shirley will be working with us as needed
Beverley Shirley demonstrated www.aclin.org -- Colorado Virtual Library
- One idea of how LOT could look
- Search specific libraries; search across user-generated groups of libraries; can include other non-MARC 21 databases
Invitation for TZIG to participate: specifics now known yet
- LRS is currently working on government information area with GODORT librarians
- Will need as much time as you would like to give: meetings, email, evaluation
- Need for customized interface -- usability engineers need to be used
- Possibly our profile will need to be adjusted in order to allow participation
- Circulation Interchange Protocol (CIP) should be involved; need CIP, ILL, and Profile need all three in order to work
- Probably need multiple vendors to accomplish full vision of LOT
- Names of consultants for future needs? Wait until LRS asks -- then email them names
- Virtual College of Texas -- some sort of communication needed between them? LRS will check
- Issues yet to be determined: central server, mirrored sites?
Creation of Profile for Full-Text/Citation Databases
- The Z Texas Profile was specifically written for MARC databases. Because of the proliferation of full-text and citation databases in this state, a profile specifically for these types of data would be a great help. We began the discussion of whether we wanted create such a profile.
Do we want to deal with MARC only databases? If so, there are implementations we can use. Most non-MARC use GRS. The consensus is that we need to broaden our scope to include non-MARC databases.
We would probably look to XML as a retrieval syntax instead of SUTRS or GRS. According to Bill Moen and Slavko Manojlovich, we would need to (not necessarily in this order):
- Decide on the requirements for full-text db searching
- Create DTD for XML
- Decide who needs to be at the table (probably a reconstitution of this group)
Decide definitely on MARC or XML or GRS or SUTRS for retrieval syntax
- Need a workshop on XML?
- List of databases to base this on? Desired access points?
- Full-text db only? Abstracting db? Indexing db?
Concern: if full-text and multiple databases have same record, which full-text record would you get (and which vendor gets that money)?
- Libraries could determine their own priority list of vendors' databases and get the one they feel more comfortable with
- Discussion needs to continue -- will talk more at the next meeting