Minutes - LoT WG Meeting 2/26/2010
This meeting convened at 10 AM with Judith Hiott, Janice Sutton, Jeannie Colson,
Betty Thompson, Edward J. Smith, Tracy Holtman, Margaret Sylvia, Chris Peterson
and Kevin Marsh present. Kathy Broyles and Beverley Shirley were absent. Mike
Avila, Jay Velgos and Susan Bennet each joined us for a portion of the meeting.
Welcome and introductions
Review of goals from last meeting - Judith Hiott
– Emphasis on 4 goals measuring use, effectiveness, participation and
– Presentation at TexShare Advisory Board and good question from Sue
Phillips about the future relationship between LoT and Navigator
Progress report since last meeting - Kevin Marsh
– Press release prepared on Widgets and full-text filtering
– Formed an EZProxy subcommittee to iron out configuration problems.
Members are Kevin Marsh, Jay Velgos, Tracy Holtman, Edward Smith and Margaret
– Usability support from the UT iSchool iXLab – MOU in work. Discussed
whether continued development of current software was justified, but tabled
that discussion until after the Navigator demo.
– Discussed urgent need for better logging support to be developed by
Index Data. Concern was expressed the Index Data work for OCLC may distract
them from meeting our needs.
Demonstration and discussion of Navigator ILL system - Susan Bennett
– Talked about the separation of “discovery” and “ILL
management” functionality, with discovery using a version of the WorldCat
– Ability for libraries to add local subscriptions only by purchasing
the full WorldCat Local service at a discounted price.
– A five year rollout plan will have Navigator in all TexShare public
libraries by 2015.
– Many discovery features like support for authenticated links to native
interfaces, etc remain to be seen.
– Navigator availability for TexShare academic libraries unclear, Susan
will look into pricing for this from OCLC.
– Prospect is there to unite all TexShare libraries in one discovery
environment in 5 years, if the discovery tools/features are all there.
Marketing challenges and ideas – Mike Avila emphasized targeting specific
messages to specific audiences. Kevin Marsh emphasized the need to market
the concept, not just a product. Starting with using information to improve
life, the use of reliable, published information, finding indexed information
in “databases”, and then one-stop discovery from diverse resources.
Many librarians and most users are unfamiliar or unconvinced about these ideas,
and there are no familiar terms that serve to easily convey the concepts.
Afternoon Brainstorming session -
“FREE” or “Already Paid For”
Start with “Knowledge is Good” and build a case for using info,
published info, indexed info, federated info from there.
Use “trustworthy” not “authoritative”
Use “one-stop finding” not “federated searching”
Keep it brief
Focus on Why not What
Avoid focus on features rather than benefits, too formal, too wordy, and unformatted/misformatted
Promote concept, not platform
Need an elevator pitch
Adult Learners – see LoT strategic plan
Receptive small library staff
Early-Mid-Late adopters need separate messages. See book “Crossing the
Users by area of interest – Genealogy, Medical, News, Business (financial,
employment), Consumer, Home/Garden improvement, Entertainment
Librarians or users – both! Separate messages. Users want content, don’t
care about method.
YouTube highly valued – tell the story of database use
Facebook page with widgets
Other “Web 2.0” social network tools
e-mail – brief and general with links to technical details
use listserves carefully, no broken HTML
Journals and newsletters, Texas Libraries, system newsletters
See study “How e-mail marketing is used”
System meetings – show YouTube video then give elevator pitch, followed
by discussion. Non-technical.
TCCJCL-TCAL fall meeting
CALLR.us – mostly community college libraries
Promote the concept, not the platform
Get pro/student/expert marketing science help. RTF/Communications students?
Pilot city – city-wide access by IP, no ID needed. Round Rock?
Branding – need a single service name for patrons Re-brand with site
Quote users in marketing materials
Reach customers to bring librarians along
Reach librarians (that are open to the concept) to bring customers along
Librarians have limited available attention
Some targeted messages:
Target: Ref. And Academic librarians
Message: Federated searching is a good place to start. Easy and Comprehensive
Target: Small town librarians (and users too)
Message: Build the concept:
Knowledge is good
Published info gives real answers to real questions (Contrast with the limitations
of the open Web/Google)
Target: All librarians
Message: Tell and show users
Place links and widgets on Web site
Buy in and Believe
Next meeting – Schedule further in advance, meet by teleconference in